Relationship Selling
I gave this talk to a room full of agency owners and freelancers. I pivoted it at the 11th hour, because I kept thinking about what would actually be useful to that room, and almost every conversation I have with people running studios comes back to the same thing — sales, deals not converting, and a process that feels awful.
What it actually means
Relationship selling means putting the client relationship first, ahead of the transaction, ahead of closing, and ahead of getting a signature on anything. The goal is to be a guiding partner to the person across from you, instead of pushing to close and figuring out the rest later.
The traditional approach is a lot like buying a car. Nobody wants to do it. It's always a shitty transaction, nobody has fun, and it's always us versus them. The salesperson knows more than you do, and you spend the whole time trying not to get screwed. You feel like you're being sold to because you are being sold to, and you know your interests aren't being accounted for.
The difference is whose side of the equation comes first. Transactional selling is about yours, and relationship selling is about theirs.
Why it works
We punch above our weight class. There have been deals recently where I knew exactly who we were up against, they were talented firms, and on paper they were probably the better fit. We won anyway. When you have a real relationship with someone, you can score lower on the rubric in a category and still win, because nobody wants to go into business with someone they don't trust. These are $5,000, $10,000, $50,000, and $100,000 decisions, and people don't sign those feeling uneasy.
Retainers get dramatically easier, too. Everyone in the agency world is chasing MRR right now. If you pitch a partnership, promise you'll grow alongside someone and take care of them, and then actually honor that through the entire project, asking for a 6- or 12-month engagement at the end is barely a conversation. You made a promise, and you kept it.
And when clients switch companies, which happens constantly in tech, you go with them. A new marketing leader takes a job, and the first thing they change is the website. If they have a partner they trust, they're not running a search.
I was terrible at this
I want to be careful not to talk about this like I solved it. I used to be so anxious about sales that I wrote literal scripts before calls, which is not a human way to have a conversation. That was 2017, and I remember exactly how low I felt.
I talk to a lot of agency owners who feel the same way and believe it will never improve. I really believe it's a muscle, and you just have to put in the reps. Sales is basically my main job now, and I honestly thought I'd never get better at it.
Everything below is a mistake I've made and am still trying to fix. If you want the front half of this, how I get to these people in the first place, that's a separate piece.
Be honest to the point of discomfort
We don't have a fiduciary duty to our clients, and almost none of us have that in a contract. I think you should act like you do anyway. People come to you for expertise, and they mostly just want to know somebody is looking out for them.
The pushback I get is that saying no, or creating any friction in a sales cycle, kills the deal forever. I don't agree. In my experience, one of three things happens:
- The door closes. That's real, and it happens.
- They find the budget. If a project is juicy but I know I can't service it well at their number, I say so, and I recommend other partners. I'm still shocked how often people find the money.
- They disappear for a while and come back. Maybe they didn't have the support internally to get it across the line. They go somewhere else, and they remember you.
We lost a deal a while back to a firm at half our price, which was understandable. A year later, they came back in an emergency because they couldn't reach their agency. We fixed it, which was easy for us because we knew how, and we didn't bill for it. A month later, that person put us on MKT1's agency recommendation list, which is invite-only and seems to be read by every marketing and sales leader at Series A and up. We billed that client zero dollars, and that list has since generated more than $250k in revenue.
Price like someone who has been burned
Most clients arrive with no idea what to spend, and many of them have been burned by vague pricing before — an estimate of hours dressed up as a fixed price, and then the thing costs double, and they're halfway through and can't walk away.
Wherever you can, give ranges and timelines early. You don't need an exact number, and I keep the range wide on purpose. I'll say something like, "I think this lands between $30k and $70k. I'll build three tiers, try to fit your scope into one of them, and give you the other two in case you want to trade scope for budget, with timelines for each. You'll have it tomorrow."
We won a large enterprise deal recently, and one of the reasons they gave was that the other firm was vague about what the engagement would actually cost.
Do what you said you would do
If a prospect is chasing you for a proposal, you're already in a bad spot. If you said Thursday with X, Y, and Z in it, they get it Thursday or earlier. It's the most basic possible bar, and it's cleared shockingly rarely. If you can't keep a small promise during the sales process, why would a client believe you'll keep bigger ones during the project?
Send recaps after calls. It's low effort, especially now, and it tells someone you were listening.
Be a search engine for your own work
I used to be so proud of our portfolio that I'd dump twenty links on someone and honestly believe they'd click all of them and be impressed. They won't, because they're busy.
If someone tells you they want to migrate to Webflow and keep a partner around long after launch, don't hand them everything you've ever made. Hand them the one thing that matches, something like, "We migrated Pilot.com to Webflow, and we've been their agency of record ever since, for about two years now. Here's that case study, and I'll send related ones by end of day."
Ask better questions
The mistake I made for years was only asking the questions I needed to write the proposal, instead of the questions I needed to run a successful project. I wouldn't learn what actually mattered to a client until we were halfway in, which is a terrible time to find out.
I still ask the templated ones, like page count, CMS structure, and team. But when I sit in on calls to help clients choose a vendor, I'm amazed how much information a client volunteers that nobody double-clicks on.
If someone says "we need this live by August 22" and "we need to manage it in house without relying on anyone," there are at least four really helpful questions hiding in there:
- Why the 22nd? Is there a conference, or is your CEO speaking somewhere?
- Does all of it need to ship, or can we phase it?
- What is managing the site like for you today?
- How technical is your team, and if they aren't, should we lean on components?
Every one of those makes the project better for you, and every one of them shows that you were listening.
My last question on every sales call is always the same: "Let's imagine we work together, and let's fast forward to the end. What would make you walk away and say we were the best damn agency you've ever worked with?"
You learn two things right away — where they've been burned, because they'll tell you, and what they actually care about. It's almost always communication and transparency.
If you want to get better at this in general, read How to Know a Person by David Brooks. It isn't a business book at all. It's about curiosity.
Make it fun
We won a big deal a few months ago, and when I asked the point of contact why she chose us, she said every person she talked to made it feel fun and light.
That stuck with me. These are complex, expensive problems with a lot of stakeholders and somebody breathing down that person's neck. The traditional process makes it you versus the client. Relationship selling makes it you and the client versus the problem, which is a much better place for both of you to stand.
The rest of it
Don't disappear. A client of ours in Toronto told me we were the only agency where the person who sold the project was still around during it. The usual pattern is that the principal gets everyone hyped, the work goes to juniors, and the principal is invisible until something's on fire. I don't join every call, and I rarely talk on the ones I do. I'm just there.
Give real gifts. We do personalized gifts for most main stakeholders now, and I credit our PM and ops teams for it entirely, because they're the ones who actually get to know people. One client kept talking about her dog, so we sent her a three-month BarkBox subscription. A gift arrives every month, and it's a reminder of your firm, but mostly it's just nice. Some people would tell me to fuck off for this, so read the room.
Show up in person. I visit clients for no reason at all — coffee, lunch, hearing how they are. I had coffee with a client in Toronto the day before her wedding. I flew to Boston to eat lunch with a fintech client, and we just hung out. Real life is monumentally better than Zoom, and I've closed far more deals by showing up than by any technique on this list. It doesn't scale, and I do it anyway.
Make it the whole team's job. If relationship selling only happens during the sales cycle and never again, that's a bait and switch. Everyone from the first salesperson to whoever does QA and handoff has a role in it. If you're a freelancer, that just means being consistent. If you have a team, it's culture.