← All writing

Unconventional Beliefs I Hold About Agency Businesses

Most of what I believe about running an agency, I learned by getting it wrong first. Some of these go against what you'll hear from a lot of other agency owners, and a couple go against things I used to say out loud myself. None of them are rules for everyone. They're just what's held up for us at 8020 after a lot of years and a lot of mistakes.

1. Every agency is in the hospitality business

I'm a big believer that almost every service business, and especially every agency, is in the hospitality business — they just might not know it yet. The work itself is table stakes, and clients expect you to have that dialed no matter what. What they remember is the service, the experience, and the communication.

Think about the last great meal you had at a restaurant. You probably don't remember the exact dish nearly as well as you remember how they made you feel. Agencies are the same. Those soft skills only matter more in a world that keeps getting more disconnected and less friendly, and they're the hardest thing for a competitor to copy. I wrote more about what that looks like in practice in Relationship Selling.

2. Track your time, even though everyone hates it

I went three years without time tracking, and honestly, I was kind of proud of it. I hate it, employees hate it, and it feels like the opposite of trusting your team.

But I was wrong. Time tracking is probably one of the most important things an agency can do, if not the most important. We finally started in year four, and today I look at time spent more than almost any other metric. It's how I judge whether a project was actually profitable, whether a type of work is a good fit for us, and how to price the next one, because we can look at similar projects and see exactly what they took. Without it, you're basically guessing, and I guessed for a long time.

3. A four-day workweek doesn't work for an agency

We tried it, and it was a terrible idea. Our clients work five days a week, and they did not like that their agency disappeared for one of them. It also ended up costing us more, not less, because the work didn't shrink to fit the week.

I understand why it's appealing, and it might work for a product company that sets its own schedule. But a service business lives on the client's calendar, not its own.

4. Hire operational help before you think you need it

I'm a people guy. I love relationships, and I hate getting into the nitty-gritty of resourcing, timelines, and who's working on what. For the first few years at 8020, that showed. Our months swung wildly between great and terrible, mostly because I didn't know how to forecast or plan resourcing.

For years, I've had a monthly call with my friend Mason Poe, who runs the agency Edgar Allan, and for a long time, I used a lot of those calls to complain about how hard running an agency was. Every time, he'd tell me he didn't understand how I was doing it on my own. He had a whole leadership team helping him run Edgar Allan, and I had no one. And every time, I brushed him off, because I didn't think that was the problem.

It was exactly the problem. When I finally brought it up over breakfast with Andrew Wilkinson, my former partner in 8020, we went back and forth on what kind of help I actually needed, and I realized it was a COO. My friend Matt Hollingsworth at Align ran the search and found Joanie, who'd been VP of Operations at an agency about five times our size. She solved problems I didn't even know how to name, and today, she's my business partner. Mason was right all along, and I was wrong for about three years longer than I needed to be.

5. Your most underrated hire is a full-time accountant

I don't mean a contract bookkeeper who shows up at tax time. I mean someone in the day-to-day of the business who does cash flow planning and modeling, gets you any report you need, and works directly with the banks.

We hired ours when Tiny, the holding company 8020 was part of at the time, went public in 2023. Being part of a public company came with real standards around banking and finance, so we brought on a full-time accountant, Ana. Honestly, I didn't realize how much we needed someone like her until she was here. She made the business legible to me in a way it never had been, she's incredible at what she does, and she's one of the best hires we've ever made.

6. Keep more cash in the business than feels necessary

We're very conservative about cash, and we keep an immense amount of it in the business as runway. In my experience, most agencies don't, and I get why. Agencies are great businesses to start because they're so light, and it's tempting to take everything out the moment it comes in. But as Mason likes to say, most agencies are always about 90 days away from going under, and I think he's right.

Admittedly, this was a real point of tension when we were part of a public company. The thinking there was that extra cash should be swept up to the parent company, and that the business should be profitable at all times. I understand why, but that model doesn't account for how volatile an agency can be, and it assumes an agency runs perfectly all the time. The reality is that clients are sometimes slow to pay, a startup loses its funding and can't pay its bills, or a big project slips by a few months. None of that is unusual, and you need cash on hand to absorb it.

A big cash cushion is what lets you stay calm when a big client pauses, a month comes in light, or the market shifts. It's also what lets you make decisions for the right reasons, instead of signing a project you shouldn't because you need to make payroll. Honestly, one of the greatest feelings in the world is being able to say no to a client who isn't a fit, simply because you know you don't need the work.

7. Be great at one small thing

We build marketing websites on Webflow, and that's it. No web apps, no React, no other platforms. I turn that work down on sales calls all the time, and I'm happy to recommend someone else when I do.

Being unreasonably focused is what lets our team get really, really good at the one thing we do. It's how we became one of the first agencies in Webflow's enterprise partner program, and it's why our processes run as well as they do. I'd much rather be world-class at that than a second-rate full-service shop. (The caveat is that you have to earn the right to say no first.)

8. Disqualify people over email

Early on, I took every single call, even when I knew in the first email that we weren't a fit, because I felt like I had to. Now, if a project is too small or just isn't right for us, I'd rather say so over email than have both of us lose an hour on a call. I still want to help people, and I'll still point them somewhere good. But protecting everyone's time is a kindness, too.

We've also automated a lot of the busywork around this. When a new lead comes in, a handful of tools pull together what we need to know about them and drop a brief into our business development channel before anyone gets on a call. It's pretty repetitive work, and it doesn't need a person to do it.

9. Value-based pricing never worked for me

There's a lot of merit in value-based pricing, and I know plenty of people swear by it. I've just never been able to make it work, and to be honest, it's always felt a little weird to me — charging someone more because of who they are rather than what the work takes.

We price on what actually drives the effort: how big the sitemap is, how much of it runs on the CMS, and how much animation it needs, plus a premium for rush timelines. We almost always give clients three options, which are exactly what they asked for, a lighter version, and the project plus a retainer. We'll sometimes discount for clients who are willing to wait to start, and we never reduce a price unless something else changes with it, like scope or timing.

10. I was wrong about retainers

When I took over 8020, the pitch was that we would never charge retainers, and that clients would own their website end to end. I still hold the second half of that very hard. Every client owns their site, gets a full set of recorded training, and can always walk away with it. We'd never change that, because that's the ethos of Webflow at its core.

But clients kept telling us they wanted a partner who could move faster than their own team could, so now that third proposal option is almost always the project plus a retainer, at a discounted project rate. It's a trade, never a discount for its own sake. And when you've actually taken care of someone through a whole project, asking for that ongoing work is barely a conversation.

11. Independence is undervalued

Being part of a bigger group taught me an enormous amount. I learned a ton directly from Andrew about selling, managing people, and thinking about incentives, and I'm grateful for it. But buying 8020 back, alongside my business partner, Joanie, made me realize how much of my energy had been going to things that had nothing to do with clients or our team.

There's no board to answer to, no signatures to chase, and no public-company standards to follow for a business our size. I'm a lot less stressed, decisions get made by the people who actually care about them, and I think the company is better for it.

12. AI is going to split agencies in two

People ask me all the time what I think AI is going to do to agencies. Honestly, I don't know for sure, and anyone who says they do is guessing. But my best guess is that it pushes agencies toward two ends of a spectrum.

On one end, you'll see a lot more tiny shops, one to three people, using AI to do the work of a much bigger agency.

On the other end, I think two kinds of agencies win. The first is consolidation, with agencies merging or getting acquired to pull talent and expertise together under one roof. I think it'll look a lot like the hotel industry. Marriott runs everything from Ritz-Carlton to Courtyard, at completely different price points, but they all share the same systems and standards behind the scenes. The second is the agency that's known for doing one thing really well, for clients who care more about trust than about price. In hotel terms, it's the Four Seasons, one brand known for doing hospitality and premium service at the highest level everywhere. That's exactly where we've put 8020, with a lot of enterprise clients and a reputation we've worked really hard to build.

The place I'd least want to be is stuck in the middle, without a clear reason for a client to pick you.